Movie "The Forgotten Battle" (Slag om de Schelde)

[Mike Cecil]

Just completed watching this movie. Some nice imagery, lots of good kit and vehicles, but some woeful continuity (the No.4/No.1 Mk.3* SMLE rifles swapping back and forth, as mentioned before) and obvious technical flaws such as an MG42 being loaded with a belt from the right side, then not cocked, and so on.

Were Canadians in Europe even using the No.1 Mk.3* rifle by late 1944?

Despite the stretch in credibility, I mostly enjoyed the story line and filming, but the overall could have easily been improved by the director taking note of some sound technical advice.

Mike

[Mike K]

Originally Posted by Mike Cecil

but the overall could have easily been improved by the director taking note of some sound technical advice.

Having been involved in a TV series with my Jeep and other MV's, in my experience I can tell you the props department will completely ignore any advice relating to vehicles, equipment and the time line of when jeeps first appeared. The response from the props team was " it's in the script so it must be correct "

[Ed Storey]

Originally Posted by Mike Cecil

Just completed watching this movie. Some nice imagery, lots of good kit and vehicles, but some woeful continuity (the No.4/No.1 Mk.3* SMLE rifles swapping back and forth, as mentioned before) and obvious technical flaws such as an MG42 being loaded with a belt from the right side, then not cocked, and so on.

Were Canadians in Europe even using the No.1 Mk.3* rifle by late 1944?

Despite the stretch in credibility, I mostly enjoyed the story line and filming, but the overall could have easily been improved by the director taking note of some sound technical advice.

Mike

Beyond the numerous technical errors in this movie, the screenplay was complete nonsense. For example, a resistance member overtly taking photographs of German troop movements while standing by the side of the road and a Glider Pilot who has been on the run from the Germans and is then somehow absorbed into the Canadian Army; other than the 'interesting kit', there is nothing to recommend to anyone about this motion picture.

[Hanno Spoelstra]

Originally Posted by edstorey

there is nothing to recommend to anyone about this motion picture.

I beg to differ; one reason is my son was an extra in this movie