H 42084 Smith, Edward, Rifleman

Originally posted by Mark W. Tonner
Hi John;

Have who noticed that the statement of both Gnr Clark, W.F. (posted above) and the account in "Conduct Unbecoming" - differ from that of Cliff Chadderton’s book "Excuse us! Herr Schicklgruber".

In both Clark's statement and in "Conduct Unbecoming", it says that the German's were armed with machine carbines (which would have been MP 40's), and yet in Chadderton’s account, it refers to the execution being carried out by vehicle mounted MG's (which would have been either MG 34's or MG 42's).

I noticed that contradiction too.