CMP F15 open cab?

cliff · #1 10-02-12, 20:35

On a modelling site I visit a new company is releasing a resin 1/35 scale F15 11 cab but it is an open cab without windscreen and roof, the cab being level at door height. When I question the fact that there was no windscreen or roof I was told that "of course they were made in this open cab style"

I know of field mods made to remove the windscreen and roof so guns can be mounted in the rear but apart from the missing roof and windscreen this is a standard 11 cab F15.

So did they make these without windscreen and roof?

Hanno Spoelstra · #2 10-02-12, 21:03

Cliff,

No, indeed they were not manufactured without roof.

The roof was often removed in service in hot climates, however.

Hanno

cliff · #3 10-02-12, 22:54

That is what I thought Hanno.

Bruce Parker (RIP) · #4 11-02-12, 00:10

I'm not so sure. I recall a reference to a series of open cabs. Something like a 43 cab was the open version of a 13 cab.

Phil Waterman · #5 11-02-12, 00:44

Did a quick search of the MLU forum it looks like the 43 Cab references all go along with the truck mounted bofors which was I believe on a 3 ton chassis.

There have been lots of period pictures of various CMPs both Ford and Chevy with the cab tops and often the windscreens removed. Closest that I have spotted to some thing that was intentionally built that way are the gun portees which had folding windscreens. Lots of North Africa pictures of various cargo trucks with improvised gun mounts where the windscreen has been removed allow firing forward.

Given the basically fragile windscreen posts on pattern 11 and 12 cabs I suspect that the removal of the cab tops was followed by the removal of the windscreen when one of the side posts failed. The design of the Pattern 13 windscreen post is much more substantial.

Cheers Phil

cliff · #6 11-02-12, 06:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bruce Parker

I'm not so sure. I recall a reference to a series of open cabs. Something like a 43 cab was the open version of a 13 cab.

I am talking about a standard cab less windscreen and roof NOT a purpose designed open cab.

The picture below which comes from Service Publications Factory Photo CD is the cab/vehicle I am talking about, and in fact the model is based on this photo.

Nigel Watson · #7 15-02-12, 16:10

Or was it just a very low bridge!

Piotr Mikolajski · #8 23-02-12, 20:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by cliff

On a modelling site I visit a new company is releasing a resin 1/35 scale F15 11 cab

LZ Models isn't new company, they released several kits. But CMP F15 Cab 11 is their new release and it's the first one from CMP family. I've received this kit yesterday and this is excellent kit.

BTW, I'm trying to find photos of F15s from 1940-1941 and Tobruk siege period. I'm not sure if Polish Carpathian Rifle Brigade could use one but they had some Polish, French, British and Australian equimpent plus some captured German and Italian. There are no complete list of vehicles and I'm not sure if I can build that kit with Polish markings.

cliff · #9 23-02-12, 22:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by Piotr Mikolajski

LZ Models isn't new company, they released several kits. But CMP F15 Cab 11 is their new release and it's the first one from CMP family. I've received this kit yesterday and this is excellent kit.

Piotr I don't doubt it is an excellent kit of a vehicle that was not supplied from the factory with no roof or windscreen.

BUT it is a pity that a model manufacturer did not do a bit more research and make the kit correct instead of basing it on one photo of a partly built truck at the factory.

Piotr Mikolajski · #10 29-02-12, 18:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by cliff

Piotr I don't doubt it is an excellent kit of a vehicle that was not supplied from the factory with no roof or windscreen.

This kit is researched a little bit deeper than just one photo. LZ Models will release several other variants including field conversions.

You shouldn't forget that modelling market has its own rights like releasing kits which are base for further conversions. Many modellers don't want to remove cab on their own, several others will not buy this kit and wait for "full cab" set.

Last but not least - you may use this kit to build this particular vehicle from the photo mentioned above so from modelling point of view it's well done.

cliff · #11 29-02-12, 18:41

you also must remember that the manufacturerer claimed to me on another site that this model was of a vehicle that came from the factory as it is with no roof or windscreen and told me to look at Service Publications Factory Photo CD for proof. Proof was one photo of a partly assembled truck. With a comment like this it is easy to believe that not much research was done and the kit was released incomplete. As to modellers having their own rights so do hotrodders and restorerers although finished vehicles are totally different between the two they both have their uniqueness.

I will not comment any further on this kit or it's maker which I believe you either are or are in close contact with except to say IT IS A NICE KIT IN MY OPINION BUT A PITY IT IS NOT OF A TRUE FACTORY FINISHED PRODUCT!

Perhaps you would like to send me a kit and I'll do an honest review of it for you!

Libor Zachoval · #12 04-03-12, 20:30

Hi guys
I dont see any problem here, I wanted this first variant released without closed cab, because it simply suits much more to modeller´s needs. Full cab variant is coming in a couple of weeks, and it will be true factory finished product then

My mistake was that I mentioned somewhere I believed it was produced also as a open cab variant. A few pictures with open cab vehicles looked very same like the others taken at factory yard and showing fully finished vehicles, and then it was easy to believe they might be finished as well. I have spent many months by doing research, but no one could give me clear and documented answer about this
Libor